TURKMENISTAN: "Shall we trust the president?" religious groups ask
Doubts have been expressed about the genuineness of this month's surprise presidential lifting of harsh restrictions on registering religious communities. But five groups – the Church of Christ, the Adventists, the New Apostolic Church, the Catholic Church and the Baha'i faith - have since the decree sought information about how to apply for registration, Forum 18 News Service has learnt. Other religious communities remain wary. At present only Russian Orthodox and some Muslim communities have registration, and these communities must now reregister. Unregistered religious activity is – contrary to international law – a criminal offence. The presidential decree will not affect the unregistered Baptists, who are persecuted for refusing on principle to seek state registration. Meanwhile the former chief mufti remains on a 22 years jail sentence, apparently for opposing tight presidential control of the Muslim community, and at least six Jehovah's Witnesses are in jail for refusing military service on grounds of religious conscience.
The currently registered Russian Orthodox and Muslim communities will have to apply again for registration. This is under new registration guidelines brought in following the harsh new 2003 religion law, which – contrary to international law – criminalises all unregistered religious activity (see F18News 5 February 2004 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=246).
Akhmedova reported that the Church of Christ, the Adventists, the Baha'is and the New Apostolic Church had come to her department since the decree was issued on 11 March for "consultations" about the registration process. "We gave them information about what documents they need to present to apply for registration," she told Forum 18 from the capital Ashgabad on 23 March. She said Ashgabad's Lutheran community had come to the ministry earlier in the year to enquire about registration, before the president's decree.
Fr Andrzej Madej, head of the Catholic mission in Turkmenistan who is based in the Vatican nunciature in Ashgabad, told Forum 18 from the city on 23 March that he had requested a meeting via the Foreign Ministry with Yagshymyrat Atamyradov, the head of the government's Gengeshi (Council) for Religious Affairs, to discuss how to register a parish in Ashgabad. At present the Catholics can only hold Masses on Vatican diplomatic territory. Their priests also enjoy diplomatic status.
Akhmedova explained to Forum 18 that the same registration system still operates as before the decree, except that the membership threshold has been lifted. "It is now much simpler," she insisted. "Registration does not depend on numbers." But she declined to speculate how many religious communities she expects to register in the wake of the change. "We have no plan on numbers. Whatever applications are lodged will be considered and registration will be given."
She declined to speculate on which of the faiths that are now illegal – including the Armenian Apostolic, Baptist, Pentecostal, Adventist, Lutheran, Hare Krishna, Jehovah's Witness, Baha'i, Jewish or Catholic faiths – would be likely to apply for and gain registration.
Akhmedova reported that 152 religious communities currently have registration, 140 of them Muslim and 12 Russian Orthodox. She claimed that "the majority" of the Muslim communities are Sunni, insisting that some are Shia although she said she had "no information" on exact numbers of registered Shia Muslim communities. Other sources claim that no Shia Muslim communities (which are generally made up of the Azeri and Iranian minorities) are registered.
The 140 registered Muslim communities are far below the estimated number of nearly 400 Muslim communities in the country. It is possible that with the lifting of the registration threshold, many more Muslim and Russian Orthodox communities will apply for registration. Forum 18 was unable immediately to reach leaders of either community to find out.
Akhmedova freely admitted that many more religious communities had registration before 1997, when under the provisions of the harsh 1996 amendments to the religion law the majority of the country's religious communities lost registration. "This was because the threshold of 500 members was brought in then."
In the late 1990s, members of a number of Christian churches tried to register a Bible Society to promote the distribution of the Christian scriptures within the country. Asked whether a Bible Society should apply for registration as a social or a religious organisation she responded: "It must apply as a religious organisation, as its activity is connected to religion."
Akhmedova said parliament is considering the amendments to the religion law to bring it into line with the presidential decree. "The changes for the better have already been sent to parliament." She said there are two changes: the requirement for 500 members is being abolished, and a new category of "religious group" – covering communities of less than 50 members – is being introduced in addition to the current category of "religious organisation", which will have a membership of over 50. "There will be no differences between the two except the name," she told Forum 18. "Religious groups will have no fewer rights than religious organisations."
She was unable to say if unregistered religious activity – criminalised when the previous amended religion law came into force last November – will remain a criminal offence. "But there won't be limits on registration, so the issue won't arise," she declared.
Asked what would happen to groups such as the Baptists of the Council of Churches – who refuse to register on principle in any of the former Soviet republics where they operate – she said she did not know. Unregistered Baptists are persecuted for their refusal to register (see F18News 26 February http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=264 ), and other Adalat Ministry officials have insisted to Forum 18 that unregistered religious activity remains illegal (see F18News 12 March 2004 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=274 ).
The Baha'i community appears optimistic. "Our community could not function since 1997 as we could not gather the required number of signatures," an unnamed representative of the faith told Reuters on 12 March. "Now we are thankful to the president for guaranteeing our religious freedom."
Asked by Forum 18 if he is optimistic that the Catholics will get registration Fr Madej responded: "Yes, I am, as this comes from a decree from the president." He added that he is waiting for news on changes to the religion law. "They haven't informed the public yet."
However, other religious leaders did not share this optimism. One Protestant leader who asked that his identity and location not been published told Forum 18 that his community is waiting until the amendments to the religion law are published before deciding whether to apply for registration. "Only God knows if we would be successful," he declared, although he is inclined to be wary after years of persecution. "Everyone is waiting for the change in the law."
"I know that the Baptists of the Council of Churches in the town of Nebit-Dag have suffered fines and a ban on their meetings as they insist on always meeting in the same place," he added. He said his communities tried to avoid punishment by constantly changing the places where they meet for worship.
Another Christian leader stressed to Forum 18 that caution was required about the changes to the registration requirement, insisting that only when religious communities have already registered and can function freely will it be safe to believe that the government has changed its policy. "We should not count chickens before they are hatched."
Also sceptical of the government's goodwill is the Turkmenistan Helsinki Initiative, a human rights group now based in exile. "We do not believe in the seriousness of the intentions of the Turkmen authorities to achieve religious freedom in the country," it declared on 21 March. "Still in force is the far-from-democratic law on freedom of conscience and religious organisations, which has been criticised by many international human rights organisations." It believes that until the law is changed, no religious community will risk applying for registration.
It cited the harassment of the Hare Krishna community in the 1990s, as well as the difficulties faced this year by Jehovah's Witnesses. On 9 March, two women from Yolatan in Mary region had been leaving Ashgabad airport to fly to Kiev for a Jehovah's Witness congress when they were stopped by border guards, who told them – after consulting the black list of citizens who cannot leave the country – that they could not join the flight. They were told to apply to the Border Directorate of the city of Ashgabad if they wanted further explanation.
One of the women told the Turkmenistan Helsinki Initiative that earlier when they had applied for exit visas from the foreign ministry with official Jehovah's Witness invitations, they had been refused more than once, attributing this to their faith.
The group also reported that police raided a Jehovah's Witness meeting in a private home in Ashgabad on 13 March, "literally the day after the president's decree came into force". Police accused those present of conducting an illegal meeting for which they could be punished and more than 20 were forcibly taken to the local police station. There they were interrogated by two men in civilian clothes who showed them identification as National Security Ministry officers. Ordering them to halt such "illegal meetings", the officers warned them that if they meet in future they will be charged under the criminal code for "inciting inter-religious and inter-ethnic hatred". They were then freed after their personal details were recorded. The Turkmenistan Helsinki Committee reported that most of those detained were women and children.
It remains unclear why President Niyazov – who rules Turkmenistan autocratically, allowing little scope for dissent – made the concession over registration of religious organisations. His decree came at the same time as a decree easing exit procedures and as 78-year-old writer Rahim Esenov was among a number of people released from prison, although charges remain. Niyazov has been under great pressure to improve the human rights situation, especially with the current United Nations Human Rights Commission in Geneva paying great attention to the abuses in the country.
In his most recent report (E/CN.4/2004/63), the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief, Professor Abdelfattah Amor, noted that his request to visit Turkmenistan in June 2003 to assess the situation on the ground did not even bring a response from the Turkmen government. (Requests by other UN rapporteurs to visit equally evinced no response.) Amor's numerous enquiries for further information about reports of violations of the rights of religious believers likewise went unanswered.
Esenov was detained by the National Security Ministry earlier this year partly for collaborating with Radio Free Europe and partly in retaliation for publishing in Moscow his novel "The Crowned Wanderer", about the historical figure Bayram Khan. Niyazov had publicly criticised the novel in February 1997 for "historical errors" he alleged it contains. Another exiled human rights group, the Turkmenistan Helsinki Foundation, reported on 27 February that during interrogation, national security officers repeatedly asked Esenov why he had made the hero of his novel a Shia rather than a Sunni Muslim as the president had required. He still faces charges of inciting social, religious and ethnic hatred under Article 177 of the criminal code.
Forum 18 has been unable to reach Esenov by telephone since his release on 9 or 10 March. An automatic response says his number cannot be reached at the moment.
Meanwhile, the former chief mufti Nasrullah ibn Ibadullah remains in prison after being sentenced to 22 years' imprisonment on 2 March (see F18News 8 March 2004 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=271 ). This jail term is apparently for his opposition to tight presidential control over the Muslim community and reportedly obstructing the use in mosques of the president's book of his moral code, the Ruhnama (Book of the Soul). Imams are forced to display this book prominently in mosques and quote approvingly from it in sermons, as are Russian Orthodox priests in their churches.
Also, at least six young Jehovah's Witness men are serving prison sentences, mostly for refusing military service on grounds of religious conscience (see F18News 9 February 2004 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=247 ). The Turkmenistan Helsinki Initiative reported on 16 February that the city court in the northern city of Dashoguz sentenced Jehovah's Witness Rinat Babadjanov to a term of several years in prison for refusing military service. "Babadjanov's relatives were not even informed where he would be detained," the group noted.
It also reported on a court case in one major town (which it did not identify) against the local Jehovah's Witness leader brought at the instigation of the general procuracy. "Since the woman cannot be charged with serious offences, she is accused of bringing up her children in a spirit of worshipping Jehovah God," the group declared.
For more background see Forum 18's report on the new religion law at
and Forum 18's latest religious freedom survey at
A printer-friendly map of Turkmenistan is available at
12 March 2004
Despite a surprise 11 March decree from President Saparmurat Niyazov lifting the requirement that a religious community must have 500 adult citizen members before it can register, officials have insisted that unregistered religious activity remains illegal. Bibi Tagieva of the Adalat (Justice) Ministry told Forum 18 that the decree does not mean that unregistered religious communities can start to meet freely in private homes. Some believers are optimistic that the decree might be a signal of a relaxation of Turkmenistan's harsh restrictions on religious communities – which have seen all Protestant, Armenian Apostolic, Shia Muslim, Jewish, Hare Krishna, Baha'i and Jehovah's Witness communities banned. "The authorities have tried up till now to use repressive measures and have understood this is unsuccessful," one Protestant told Forum 18. "They seem now to be trying to bring religious communities under state control – perhaps a cleverer policy."
8 March 2004
Reliable sources in Turkmenistan have told Forum 18 News Service that they believe the country's former Sunni Muslim chief mufti, Nasrullah ibn Ibadullah, was sentenced to a long jail term for his opposition to tight presidential control over the Muslim community. Government prosecutors claimed he was part of an assassination attempt against the president. Although previously known for his obedience, Ibadullah began to oppose the cult of personality around the president by reportedly obstructing the use in mosques of the president's moral code Ruhnama (Book of the Soul). Imams are forced to display this book prominently in mosques and quote approvingly from it in sermons, as are Russian Orthodox priests in their churches. Ibadullah is also believed to have been targeted as an ethnic Uzbek, Forum 18 having noted the government removing ethnic Uzbek imams to replace them with ethnic Turkmens.
4 March 2004
The Turkmen government has been replacing ethnic Uzbek imam-hatybs (mosque leaders) with ethnic Turkmens, Forum 18 News Service has learnt. The authorities are also forcing imam-hatybs to place the Turkmen flag above mosque entrances, to begin every sermon by praising "Turkmenbashi", "Father of the Turkmens", as President Saparmurat Niyazov insists on being called. Also, a copy of Niyazov's book, the Ruhnama (Book of the Soul), must be placed at the entrance to every mosque and Muslims must touch it as if it were a sacred object. Similar instructions have reportedly been given to other Sunni Muslim mosques and Russian Orthodox Churches. These are the only two confessions allowed some limited freedom to operate in Turkmenistan.