KYRGYZSTAN: Extradition overturned, but new charges and transfer to prison close to Uzbekistan
The appeal in Kyrgyzstan by Uzbek former imam Khabibullo Sulaimanov against his extradition back to Uzbekistan has been upheld, Forum 18 News Service notes. The successful appeal followed his being recognised as a refugee by the Bishkek office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) – but he was immediately afterwards detained again and sent by the NSC secret police to a prison in Osh, very close to the border with Uzbekistan. "We had to tell the lawyer – no one had told him of the transfer," Sulaimanov's wife Albina Karankina told Forum 18. She complained that no one would tell the family why he was transferred to Osh, where he is being held and what the new accusations against him are. His lawyer Toktogul Abdyev understands that the new charges relate to an alleged illegal border crossing in 2012, but the UNHCR is "waiting for an official confirmation concerning his transfer and charges brought against him". The NSC secret police would not tell Forum 18 what new charges Sulaimanov faces. But officials confirmed that he is in the Osh Region NSC Investigation Prison.
The Bishkek office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), which observed the latest appeal hearing, welcomed the overturning of the extradition decision. They and others feared that were Sulaimanov to undergo refoulement (return to "territories where his life or freedom would be threatened on account of his race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion"), he would be at risk of torture (see F18News 6 February 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1799).
"UNHCR welcomes Bishkek City Court decision of 1 March and hopes that the country will strictly follow its non-refoulement obligation under international refugee and human rights law," the Bishkek UNHCR office told Forum 18 on 9 March.
The UNHCR has previously pointed out to Forum 18 that Sulaimanov "is protected from refoulement in accordance with Article 33 of the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees which the Kyrgyz Republic acceded to" (see F18News 28 January 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1795).
Appeal against extradition upheld
On the afternoon of 1 March, a panel of three judges at Bishkek City Court - Zhanyl Mambetaly, Mederbek Satyev and Muslim Sultanaliyev – overturned the Pervomaisky District Court decision from December 2012 and ordered that Sulaimanov's appeal against the General Prosecutor's Office extradition order be re-heard by the lower court.
On 27 February, two days before the hearing, UNHCR recognised his status as a refugee (see below). The UNHCR Refugee Certificate, seen by Forum 18, testifies to Sulaimanov's status and insists that he "should, in particular, be protected from forcible return to a country where [he] would face threats to [his] life or freedom".
Sulaimanov was not brought to the courtroom, Mihra Rittmann, Central Asia researcher for Human Rights Watch who was present in court, told Forum 18. "The representative from the Prosecutor General's office was not there, although the other prosecutorial representative was there." Observing the hearing, as in previous hearings, were representatives from the UNHCR, the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), and a number of diplomats.
Sulaimanov's lawyer Toktogul Abdyev presented a copy of Sulaimanov's UNHCR Refugee Certificate to the court almost immediately after the hearing began, Rittmann told Forum 18. The prosecution was given an opportunity to review the certificate. Then the court gave Sulaimanov's lawyer the floor to make his closing statement. He reiterated previous arguments and asked that Sulaimanov be released and the extradition order be found illegal.
After the prosecution made their closing statement, the court called a recess, Rittmann said. When the judges returned after approximately 15 minutes, they ruled that the December 2012 court decision be overturned.
Sulaimanov's lawyer Abdyev told Forum 18 that Bishkek City Court has still not issued its decision in writing, he told Forum 18 from Bishkek on 11 March.
Transfer to Osh secret police prison
However, despite Sulaimanov's successful challenge to the extradition order's legality and despite his status as a UNHCR-recognised refugee, his family told Forum 18 that they learnt on 2 March that he had been transferred to Osh. The southern city is a one-hour flight or a 12-hour road journey from Bishkek, and is very close to Kyrgyzstan's border with Uzbekistan.
"We had to tell the lawyer – no one had told him of the transfer," Sulaimanov's wife Albina Karankina told Forum 18 from Bishkek on 6 March. She complained that no one would tell the family why he was transferred to Osh, where he is being held and what the new accusations against him are.
On 4 March Judge Tursunbai Aybatiyev of Osh City Court approved Sulaimanov's detention for an initial two-month period in the Osh Region NSC Investigation Prison as the case is being investigated, the court chancellery told Forum 18 on 7 March.
Karankina told Forum 18 she knew nothing of this hearing until Forum 18 had told her. Neither she – nor anyone else connected with the case known to Forum 18 – has been able to get a copy of the court decision.
Sulaimanov's lawyer Abdyev told Forum 18 that although he has not been able to travel from Bishkek to Osh to collect the written decision, he has already challenged it to Osh Regional Court. He said he plans to travel to Osh on 15 March to collect the court decision and work on the case locally.
Kyal (he refused to give his last name), the Deputy Head of Osh Region NSC Investigation Prison, confirmed that they are holding Sulaimanov. "I have seen him," he told Forum 18 from Osh on 11 March. "His health is OK, he is not ill." Asked if Sulaimanov has been beaten in the prison, the Deputy Head responded: "We don't beat or torture people here. We don't touch those we arrest."
What are the new charges?
Deputy Head Kyal of the NSC secret police Investigation Prison refused to discuss the nature of the charges against Sulaimanov, or give the name of the NSC investigator.
The officer who answered the general number of the NSC secret police in Osh refused to discuss Sulaimanov's case with Forum 18 on 11 March. The officer – who would not give his name – also refused to put Forum 18 through to any other officer who might be familiar with the case.
Sulaimanov's lawyer Abdyev told Forum 18 that his client is facing accusations under Criminal Code Articles 346 ("Illegal crossing of the state border") and 350 ("Forgery, manufacture, or sale of falsified documents, government awards, stamps, seals, and forms"). Both charges apparently relate to an alleged illegal border crossing in 2012.
Article 346 has a maximum penalty for an individual who has not used violence of three years' imprisonment. Article 350 has a maximum punishment for use of forged or false documents, for example for travel, of two years' imprisonment.
Sulaimanov's lawyer Abdyev said the Investigator, whose surname is Dzhenbayev, is from the NSC secret police. "I don't know why the case is in the hands of the NSC," Abdyev told Forum 18.
The UNHCR is seeking official confirmation of the latest accusations against Sulaimanov. "We have received information from Mr Sulaimanov's family that he was transferred to Osh on 2 March 2013," the UNHCR told Forum 18. "Currently we are waiting for an official confirmation concerning his transfer and charges brought against him."
UNHCR grants refugee status, Kyrgyzstan refuses to process asylum
Despite obstruction by the General Prosecutor's Office and the NSC, the UNHCR was able to conduct a brief interview with Sulaimanov in the Bishkek NSC Investigation Prison on 9 January, and a more extensive interview on 8 February (see F18News 26 February 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1806).
As noted above, Sulaimanov's UNHCR Refugee Certificate insists that he "should, in particular, be protected from forcible return to a country where [he] would face threats to [his] life or freedom". The Certificate notes that Sulaimanov had entered Kyrgyzstan in 1999 at Uzgen in Osh Region.
However, Forum 18 has been unable to find out why Kyrgyzstan's Youth, Employment and Labour Ministry, which also handles asylum issues, is still refusing to process Sulaimanov's asylum application in Kyrgyzstan. The telephone of the Head of the Ministry's Refugee Department, Bazarkul Kerimbayeva, went unanswered each time Forum 18 called on 11 March.
"The refusal to process Sulaimanov's asylum application is a gross violation of his rights," his lawyer Abdyev told Forum 18. "They couldn't meet him and process the application in more than three months. They were deliberately dragging their feet."
Sulaimanov lodged his asylum application in November 2012 while he was in detention. However, the Ministry has repeatedly refused to process this. Sulaimanov's lawyer Abdyev strongly criticised this failure in a 20 February appeal to the President (see F18News 26 February 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1806).
Detained by NSC secret police from October 2012
The NSC secret police originally arrested Sulaimanov at the family home in Bishkek on 6 October 2012. He was held from the following day until 1 March 2013 in the Bishkek NSC Investigation Prison, where he was denied access to any visitors – including from his family - except his lawyer and the UNHCR (see F18News 26 February 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1806).
Sulaimanov's arrest followed an extradition request from Uzbekistan, which accused him of being a fundamentalist and a terrorist. The criminal charges facing him in Uzbekistan carry a maximum 15 years' imprisonment. In November 2012, an Investigator at Kyrgyzstan's General Prosecutor's Office approved Sulaimanov's extradition. Sulaimanov denied the charges and challenged the extradition order (see F18News 28 January 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1795).
Since late 2012, Sulaimanov has faced successive court hearings about both the extradition order itself, and also his detention by the NSC secret police (see F18News 26 February 2013 http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1806). (END)
For background information see Forum 18's Kyrgyzstan religious freedom surveys at http://www.forum18.org/Analyses.php?region=30.
More reports on freedom of thought, conscience and belief in Kyrgyzstan can be found at http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?query=&religion=all&country=30.
A compilation of Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) freedom of religion or belief commitments can be found at http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php?article_id=1351.
A printer-friendly map of Kyrgyzstan is available at http://education.nationalgeographic.com/education/mapping/outline-map/?map=Kyrgyzstan.
26 February 2013
The wife of Uzbek former imam Khabibullo Sulaimanov has spoken of her concern for her husband, detained since October 2012 by Kyrgyzstan's NSC secret police. "I'm very worried that they could extradite him back to Uzbekistan," Albina Karankina told Forum 18 News Service. "We want him freed. It is very hard for the children to live without their father." She observed that "they [Kyrgyz authorities] keep delaying the case" in court. Sulaimanov's next appeal hearing against his deportation is due at Bishkek City Court on 1 March. Karankina has been denied access to her husband in detention, and called for the "fight for justice" for him to continue. "We're grateful to all who have shown concern for us," she told Forum 18. Sulaimanov's only "crime" in Uzbekistan was to lead religious communities. The Bishkek office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) told Forum 18 that Sulaimanov is protected under international human rights law against refoulement, or being sent back to his home country.
6 February 2013
The legal appeal by former imam Khabibullo Sulaimanov against his extradition from Kyrgyzstan back to Uzbekistan resumes on 12 February, Forum 18 News Service has learned. Officials failed to produce Sulaimanov for the first hearing yesterday (5 February). His lawyer argued in court that if Sulaimanov is returned to Uzbekistan, he is likely to face torture. However, Kyrgyzstan's General Prosecutor's Office, which wants to send him back, insisted to Forum 18 – against overwhelming documented evidence - that "the risk or basis to believe that torture would be used against Sulaimanov does not exist". Sulaimanov's wife, Albina Karankina, calls for the proposed extradition of her husband to Uzbekistan to be halted. "We also want him to be freed from the Investigation Prison", she told Forum 18. Human rights defenders continue to condemn the possible extradition, but the General Prosecutor's Office denied to Forum 18 that it had received an appeal letter on the case from Human Rights Watch. The letter in English and in Russian was submitted to the General Prosecutor's Office in hard copy on 1 February, and signed confirmation of receipt was given. Apart from one five minute visit, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees has not been allowed access to Sulaimanov, and family members have been refused visits.
28 January 2013
Khabibullo Sulaimanov – who led a mosque in the Uzbek capital Tashkent and is seeking asylum in Kyrgyzstan - is fighting extradition back to Uzbekistan. "If the former imam is handed back to Uzbekistan, he faces torture and conviction on fabricated charges of 'extremism'", insists Vitaly Ponomarev of Memorial, who is among human rights defenders following the case. Sulaimanov was detained by Kyrgyzstan's NSC secret police in October 2012. "I can only see him at court hearings, and we can talk together for no more than five or ten minutes," his wife Albina Karankina told Forum 18 News Service. Tursunbek Akun, Kyrgyzstan's human rights Ombudsperson told Forum 18 that "extraditing Sulaimanov back to Uzbekistan would violate our international human rights obligations. (..) I will use all my authority and influence to prevent Sulaimanov's extradition." In sharp contrast, Kanabek Uzakbayev of Kyrgyzstan's General Prosecutor's Office, asked by Forum 18 about breaking international law by sending an individual back to Uzbekistan where they might face torture, responded: "Let them [the Uzbek authorities] do it. It doesn't bother me at all." The next appeal hearing is due on 5 February in Kyrgyzstan's capital Bishkek.